Choosing the right kitchen cookware can be overwhelming. With so many brands and options available, it’s hard to know which set is best for your needs. We’ll compare Calphalon Select vs Premier to help you decide which one is right for you. Both sets are high-quality, but there are a few key differences that may make one better suited for your cooking style. Let’s analyze the pros and cons to see.
Table of Contents
Calphalon Select vs Premier Comparison Chart 2023 :
Model | Calphalon Premier | Calphalon Select |
Price | ||
Our Rating | ||
Construction | Full-clad | Impact-bonded base |
Materials | Stainless steel and aluminum | Stainless steel and aluminum |
Thickness | 3.6mm heavy-gauge hard-anodized aluminum | 3mm medium-gauge hard-anodized aluminum |
Non-Stick Surface | 3 layers of PTFE | 2 layers of PTFE |
Handle | Stainless steel | Stainless steel wrapped in silicone |
Interlocking Grooves | Yes | Yes |
Maximum Temperature | 450 degrees Fahrenheit | 400 degrees Fahrenheit |
Oven and Broiler Use | Yes | Not broiler-safe |
Collection | Space-saving, stainless steel, and hard-anodized aluminum non-stick | Space-saving, oil-infused ceramic non-stick, cast iron, stainless steel, and hard-anodized aluminum non-stick |
Construction :
The difference between the Select and Premier lines is like night-and-day even though they are made of the same materials. The full clad cookware in this Premier means that there are multiple metals bonded together to create one durable product, which will distribute heat evenly across your pan without any hotspots or cold zones because of its aluminum layer running through it throughout; making for an efficient use out whatever energy you put into cooking .
With its impact-bonded base cookware, Select lines pots and pans are designed with an aluminum layer that’s bonded to the bottom only. This construction method reduces heat concentration on just one side which can result in longer cooking times compared to full clad counterparts who have their material spread evenly throughout each surface area. The pot or pan’s strength also depends upon how well it has been put together. That’s why it’s not sturdy like Primer .
When compared to their counterparts, the heavier gauge of metal used in building up a grill provides more durability and stability. The 3mm aluminum on select lines can get deformed easily while Primer with 3,6 mm has been found not only easier for cooking food evenly but also able to retain heat better which means that you will be able to consume your meal at its optimal temperature much quicker . Also read : Read more: Calphalon Signature vs Premier
- Impact-bonded aluminum base distributes heat evenly, for exceptional browning, searing, and sauteing
- Stainless steel long handles stay cool on the stovetop
- Convenient measuring marks, pour spouts, and straining covers allow you to cook with efficiency
- Dishwasher-safe for easy cleanup
- Oven-safe up to 450 degrees F, so you can easily go from stovetop to the oven
- Tempered glass lids
- Compatible with most stovetops, including induction, gas, electric, and glass
- Lifetime warranty
- Included with set: 8″ fry pan, 10″ fry pan, 1.5-qt. sauce pan with cover, 2.5-qt. sauce pan with cover, 3-qt. saute pan with cover, 7-qt. dutch oven with cover
- Built to last, with a 1.5x more durable nonstick interior (vs Calphalon Classic)
- Heavy-gauge, hard-anodized aluminum construction heats evenly for precision cooking and performance
- Oven-safe up to 500 degrees F, so you can easily go from stovetop to the oven
- Metal-utensil-safe, with a durable, PFOA-free, 3-layer nonstick interior
- Stainless steel long handles stay cool on the stovetop
- Recognized as BEST Overall Nonstick Cookware by Good Housekeeping
- Included with the set: 8″ fry pan, 10″” fry pan, 1-quart sauce pan with cover, 2-quart saucepan with cover, 3-quart saute pan with cover, 6-quart stockpot with cover
- Hard-anodized aluminum cookware is durable and resists corrosion and warping
- Durable, 2-layer nonstick interior prevents food from sticking and makes cleanup effortless
- Long silicone handles stay cool on the stovetop
- Oven-safe up to 400 degrees F, so you can easily go from stovetop to oven
- Tempered glass lids
- Covered by a 10-year warranty
- Built to last, with MineralShield nonstick technology that’s 5x more durable than before (vs. previous generation of Calphalon Classic)
- Metal-utensil-safe with a long-lasting, 3-layer nonstick interior
- Dishwasher-safe for easy cleanup
- Oven-safe up to 450 degrees F, so you can easily go from stovetop to oven
- Long handles stay cool on the stovetop
- Set includes: 10-inch Frying Pan and 12-inch Frying Pan
- Compatible with most stovetops, including gas, electric, and glass
- Lifetime warranty
- Included with set: 10″ fry pan 12″ fry pan
- Built to last, with 40% longer lasting nonstick (vs. Calphalon Classic)
- Metal-utensil safe, with a durable, 3-layer, hard-anodized aluminum interior
- Dishwasher safe for easy cleanup
- Oven-safe up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit, so you can easily go from stovetop to the oven
Design :
The Premier line of non-stick cookware is made with 3 layers of PTFE or it called Teflon, which gives it an advantage over the Select series that only contains two layers. The extra layer provides more durability and protection against scratches for those who use their pans without worrying about damage even if you use metal tools on them. You can only use the wooden spoon as well as nylon on the Select line .
Their handle design is another difference you should notice. While both lines come with stainless steel handles, the one on the Select line has silicone while Premier products offer more durability and grip for cooking at higher temperatures in an oven. We think that makes it worth considering if your choice were between these two top brands .
These clever grooves make it easy to stack your pans. The Premier and Select lines have something in common though, they’re both designed with a simple yet effective solution that keeps the pots from shifting or toppling over when placed on top of each other .
Temperature :
The Premier line has a much higher maximum temperature than the Select, so it’s perfect for those who need their pans to withstand extreme conditions. You can throw this stuff into boiling water or an oven without worrying about what will happen, the limited temperature is up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit while Select just can endure at 400 degrees Fahrenheit .
Those who love to experiment in the kitchen have a lot of options to cook. The Premier line is perfect for doing so, while another brand should be avoided when using them as broilers or ovens because they’re not safe under those circumstances .
Collection :
It’s not just about the quality of cookware, but also how many choices you have when shopping for it. The Premier line offers 45 variations that include both hard-anodized aluminum nonstick pots and pans as well stainless steel .
While the Select line only has 11 variations, they are all unique and interesting in their own way. For example, there’s a ceramic nonstick that will make your food taste better than ever before. There is also cast iron cookware for those who want more choice, stainless steel provides an excellent quality material as well so you can have nothing but top results every time without worrying about wear-and-tear on either piece because this stuff lasts forever, with Primer goes with stainless steel and hard-anodized aluminum non-stick .
Verdict :
The Calphalon Premier line of cookware is better than the Select option in more ways than one. It’s thicker, constructed much sturdier, and can handle higher temperatures, plus they give you access to a wide range of pots & pans that will suit any need – what else could someone ask for? So if investing your money into kitchen equipment then go ahead and invest big time because this brand has never let you down before .
FAQ - Calphalon Select vs Premier 2023 :
What are the Calphalon Premier and Select lines made of ?
Hard-anodized aluminum and stainless steel are the key materials used to make up both lines. they offer great benefits, such as anti-corrosion and durability over time .
Which one is more durable, the Calphalon Premier or Select line ?
The difference in durability between the Premier and Select lines is night and day. The former has more layers, it’s thicker, and has more layers of non-stick coating not only does this make them better but also ensures that they’ll be able to withstand rigorous use without showing any signs of wear or tear .
Which one can tolerate higher temperatures, the Calphalon Premier or Select line ?
The difference between a Select and Premier line is the maximum heat they can withstand. The first line only has 400 degrees, which makes it unable to be used in ovens or broilers, the second line does better work at 450 degrees Fahrenheit .
Which one should you buy, the Calphalon Premier or Select line ?
With all the features and benefits that come with these products, we think it’s clear to say there is no other choice than to choose a pan from Landmann’s Premier Line .
Which type of Calphalon is best ?
There is no “best” type of Calphalon. It all depends on your needs and preferences .
For example, if you’re looking for a non-stick pan, then you’ll want to get a Calphalon Contemporary Non-Stick set. But if you’re looking for an All-Clad set, then you’ll need to get the Calphalon Tri-Ply Stainless Steel set .
So it really depends on what you’re looking for in a cookware set. Do some research and find the set that’s best suited for your needs .
[…] When we talk about cookware, Circulon is one of the most durable brands on earth. They use a hard-anodized aluminum material that can withstand temperatures up to 400°F / 204 °C in the ovens and also feature silicone handles that are resistant against high heat – perfect for cooking meals with great flavor . Also read : Read more: Calphalon Select vs Premier 2022 […]